I realize tastes very, and you might grade different sorts of films differently, but I was aghast that in the April 1st issue of Entertainment Weekly, the DVD review section gives a B+ to the new Criterion Kagemusha DVD, and an A- to a special edition of Orgazmo. You might argue this is based on the extras, rather than the film itself, but the Kagamusha review mentions an “outstanding commentary”.
I’ll don’t think I’ll regret having bought the lower rated disc.