Great moments in miscasting…

I knew that Henry Fonda had once starred in a big budget adaptation of War & Peace but had never seen any of it. However, it was showing last night on TCM as part of their day of Audrey Hepburn movies (in August, the channel spends each day showing films of one star, which is kind of neat).  Flipping around, I saw a bit of it, and was must aghast.

In the scene I watched, Fonda, playing Frenchman (!!) Pierre Bezukov, is walking down a street with (I think) Mel Ferrer. Fonda is wearing old-timey Euro garb, and none too convincingly, but it’s when he opens his mouth and delivers Tolstoy with his broad Nebraska twang and trademark drawling cadence that my mouth just fell open. He was worse than Kevin Costner playing an Englishman in Robin Hood Prince of Thieves.

This scene doesn’t quite spotlight his inappropriateness, since it’s contained and the close-ups mitigate the setting. (They don’t allow this video to be embedded, so follow the link.)  Still, it gives you a taste.
Very strange.

  • Ericb

    I haven’t seen the movie but in the novel Pierre Bezukov is the illegitimate son of a Russian nobleman and is not French (he was educated abroad though and is a fish out of water in Russian society).

    Is this as bad a John Wayne as Gengis Khan?

  • Well, Ferrer called him a Frenchman in the scene, but maybe it was meant as a joke.

    I didn’t see the whole film, and topping Wayne as Khan is a sizable task, but Fonda’s in spitting room, anyway. A very strange choice.

  • Anders S

    I’ve seen a young Anthony Hopkins play Pierre Bezukov in a BBC-series from the 70’s. As Ericb said, he’s Russian in the book (and was in the TV-series as well), and it would be incredibly idiotic to turn him into a Frenchman for a whole bunch of reasons, particularly if they kept his Russian surname. But casting Fonda as Pierre isn’t exactly a sign of great intelligence, so…

  • Ericb

    Speeking of Hopkins, he was a rather strange choice to play Richard Nixon in Oliver Stone’s Nixon.

  • John M. Hanna

    At least Fonda was still playing a white guy. Wayne (and everyone else in “The Conquerer” for that matter) was trying to convince us he was Asian.

  • Ericb

    There was Charlton Heston as a Mexican cop in Touch of Evil. I bet Ricardo Montalban would have been perfect for that role. Unfortunately he was actually Mexican.

  • Toby

    Mary Steenbergen in Philadelphia. Did not work for a second.

  • Heston is miscast in Touch of Evil, but then again, Orson Welles never would have gotten to direct the movie if big star Heston hadn’t insisted on it. So the role could have gone to a more appropriate actor, and a classic film never would have been made.