Monster of the Day #3419

I sure it will shock few of you to learn that I greatly enjoyed Godzilla Minus One. Even aside from the pleasure of hanging out all weekend with Sandy and Wendy and Rev, and watching lots of junk, the movie itself nearly justified flying down to Dallas to see. Well, I mean, I could have also seen it here, but you get me.

The big question seems to be is it better than Shin Godzilla. First, Shin Godzilla was a marvel. So even having GMO in the conversation is very impressive. I’m going to wimp out and say they are both so good that it probably comes down to personal preferences.

SG had more of a point and certainly more of a general political point, while GMO has it’s post-wartime setting and more involving characters. I’d say the strongest compliment for the latter is indeed that the film remained entirely absorbing even when Godzilla was offscreen for 20 or 30 minutes. That’s a benchmark that many G-films in the past have failed to achieve.

Nor is this to say that the Godzilla segments aren’t great, because they are. Godzilla looks spectacular here in a film that cost less than a twentieth of what The Marvels did. And the film is full of neat little callbacks to the original film, presented with little twists or additions. You don’t have to be a huge Godzilla nerd to enjoy the film, but as with all the better geek movies, there are plenty of additional pleasures to be found for those that are.

I’m made little secret of the fact that I get most of my modern entertainment from Japan. Indeed, Miyazaki’s brand new movie Boy and the Heron hits theaters this weekend, and you can bet I’ll be seeing it. It’s a sign of how generally popular such fare is, though, that Godzilla Minus Zero grossed 11 and a half million dollars this week to come in third at the US box office, with an extremely good $5000 per theater average.

This is especially impressive given that the film is currently only available in a Japanese language version. I think the youngsters’ comfortableness with subtitled anime is probably making such fare more and more accessible to general audiences.  However, given the film’s success already, and with theaters starving for things to fill up all those multiplex screens, I wouldn’t be surprised if they released a dubbed version. (Unless, of course, Toho just doesn’t want that.)

  • Gamera977

    Just went to see ‘Godzilla: Minus One’ today and… well WOW it was superb! Best movie I’ve seen in years, maybe IMHO the best Godzilla movie ever. My favorite Kaiju film is ‘Gamera 3: Revenge of Iris’ and this one is close to as good, maybe better.

    Guess I’m weird that I really didn’t get that much out of ‘Shin Godzilla’. Too much as I think Nathan Shumate put- ‘hot bureaucratic wrangling’. GMO was more of a ground level film about regular people rather than the movers and shakers. I really liked the characters, even with them on the screen most of the time I never felt bored or wanting the film to get back to the Kaiju scenes. Frankly it reminded me of the Japanese film ‘The Eternal Zero’ with Godzilla! (And TEO is a masterpiece itself)

    And as a big WWII buff with an interest in Imperial Japan I was as happy as a fat kid eating cake. Lots of beautiful shots of former Imperial Navy warships and a really cool experimental plane pops up at the end. It was just pure awesome in seeing it fly even if it’s just CGI.

    Why can’t Hollywood do anything even a tenth as good as this? I’m with Ken, only it’s Asian film in general rather than just Japanese. When I was on vacation most of what I watched was Korean and Chinese movies. Let Hollywood stay on strike, I don’t friggin’ care anymore…

  • Eric Hinkle

    Everything I’ve heard about Godzilla Minus One makes it sound like a must-see. Things are tight here right now with the holidays but I’ll have to see what I can do.

    I love that picture above. “What did I tell you about feeding him, Eiji? Now he’s following us home and we’ll never be rid of him!”

  • Gamera977

    I was thinking ‘We need a MUCH bigger boat!!!’

    Or a bigger -explodey thingee-! (I don’t want to give away any spoilers)

    I only saw it on a regular screen in 2D, but it’s worth it Eric, it’s a fantastic film.

  • Eric Hinkle

    I will admit that my one, very small and quite unjust, qualm about seeing the film is over Japan’s tendency to try to use the early Godzilla films as an argument for ‘we were victimized by the Americans in 1945 for no reason’.

    Between listening to older family members who fought against Japan during WW2 and reading a lot of history, I tend to get a little steamed by that argument.

  • Toho was talking a Cinematic Universe, so I hope this movies success will push for more like it. I would love, absolutely love, a Rodan remake. He’s my favorite non-Godzilla and I don’t think he gets as much respect as he should.

  • Ken_Begg

    No, I agree it’s Asian media in general. While a lot of it unsurprisingly comes from Japan–anime, manga, films–there’s little doubt that K-dramas and the like have already planted a foot here. I’d love to see the demographic numbers on all the K-dramas Netflix is increasingly investing in. Certainly the fact that so many are romances, contemporary or historical, indicates that they are popular women. It’s also like a lot of women would rather watch an old-fashioned love story about a handsome guy slow burn wooing a lady rather than kick-ass strong women characters.

  • Ken_Begg

    There is really none of that, at least that I could detect. Indeed, the central locale isn’t bombed out Hiroshima or Nagasaki but Tokyo after the firing bombing. (Although still done by Americans, obviously. Also, I sadly expect many people here won’t even understand that Tokyo wasn’t A-bombed.) I’ve seen the usual social media meatheads try to mock “alt right-wingers” for liking the film, not getting that “it’s anti-American.” Maybe, but I didn’t detect anything like that. The Americans are kept offstage by repeated references to Cold War tensions with the Soviets, but it never struck me as criticism, but instead an explanation for why the US was not getting involved.

  • Ken_Begg

    That would indeed be fabulous.

  • zombiewhacker

    It would be quite the remarkable achievement for a Miyazaki and a Godzilla movie finish first and second place atop a US weekend box office, but at this point (Saturday evening) that appears to be where we’re headed.

  • Eric Hinkle

    Thanks. I figured my worries were seriously misplaced but I wanted to hear it from someone who actually saw the film.

  • Eric Hinkle

    Add in a ‘Me Too’ for a well-done remake of Rodan.

  • Ken_Begg

    It turned out to the first and a close third, with GMO earning a good deal more per theater than the second place Hunger Games. And again, remember, Godzilla is only available in Japanese language which presumably cost it at least a little. Indeed, the only films at the box office this weekend to top Hunger Games $2500 per theater were Boy and the Heron ($4700 per), Godzilla Minus One ($3300 per) and the Bollywood Animal ($3650 per).

    I’ll say this for Hunger Games 4 or whatever it is, it’s wisely moderate budget of $100 million means it will be at least somewhat profitable, it not nearly a blockbuster. But by the stands of The Marvels and Wish, that’s still an amazing feat.

  • NathanShumate

    Always love to check a comments thread and find my name — and what’s more, it’s not used as an epithet.

    I was especially surprised that the director of G-1 greatly admired Shingojira, since I thought that G-1 managed to avoid everything I hated about Shingojira.

  • I think that also accounts for the endless popularity (and viral propagation) of Hallmark/Lifetime Christmas romances, despite the fact that most aren’t cinematic masterpieces. Apparently, a lot of women still want to be swept off their feet by the handsome prince, etc. no matter how much Disney is struggling to convince them otherwise. Apparently most of them also want to be saved from their exciting, modern, sex-in-the-city lives of corporate drudgery in favor of something more traditional. And I really don’t think I’m reading too much into that.

  • Ken_Begg

    Great, here’s Nathan, Shumating the bed again.

    Seriously, dude, great to hear from you. Happy holidays!

  • Gamera977

    Well I really liked how you put it Mr. Shumate. I wanted to give you credit though. Merry Christmas and the best in 2024 to you!