What’s your favorite non-classic ’50s sci-fi film?

We could debate what at the ten greatest ‘50s sci-fi films, and perhaps we shall someday. There are so many that my actually favorite monster movie of all time (which is saying something), Them!, probably wouldn’t make that list. On the other hand, there would be a spot available, for me, since I long ago have removed The Day the Earth Stood Still from that roster. The older I get the more horrified I am by the film’s outright fascist politics, dressed up and obfuscated by a shiny patina of progressivism.

Even so, I imagine why there might be some debate on the margins, the general list would be nearly universally agreed upon: The Thing from Another World, Forbidden Planet, The Incredible Shrinking Man, Invasion of the Body Snatchers, War of the Worlds, Beast from 20,000 Fathoms (or arguably Gojira/Godzilla King of the Monsters), Creature from the Black Lagoon, etc. Many would no doubt still nominate The Day the Earth Stood Still, which just as a movie—if you ignore it’s message—is pretty amazing.  There are two really good Quatermass Movies, and if you expand sci-fi to social satire, there’s The Man With the White Suit.

Anyway, we’ll shelve that discussion for now. However, those films at the end there raise an interesting question that is more personal. What film do you personally really, really like even if it is in no way one of the decade’s classics.

For me, that would be The Land Unknown. It’s an odd choice, in that it stays away from the decade’s obsession (or cynical and often lazy exploitation) of atomic energy and weapons as a plot element. It’s your classic Lost World picture, with more in common with Willis’s classic silent film, or King Kong, or The Land that Time Forgot.

Although often viewed as a ‘B’, The Land Unknown—as discussed by Tom Weaver in his typically expert and entertainment commentary on the Kino Lorber Blu Ray release—was actually Universal’s most expensive sci-fi film of the 1950s. Although Weaver didn’t have exact budget figures for The Incredible Shrinking Man, he confirms that film cost less than The Land Unknown. The latter film cost more than even Universal’s much heralded color space opera This Island Earth.

Indeed, The Land Unknown was itself meant to be shot in color. However, the dinosaur suits cost so much that they had to revert to black and white. As with Them!, this actually works to the film’s benefit, providing loads of atmosphere that would be missing in color. The Land Unknown was even shot in CinemaScope, no doubt to showcase the gigantic Lost World set. This presumably along with the monster suits and puppets, ate up the majority of the hefty budget. Also, it’s actually sets. For instance, they had to recreate much of the set (all of it?) in 1/3rd scale for scenes featuring the nine foot tall T-Rex suit.

Running a thrifty 78 minutes, The Land Unknown cuts to the chase by using a stock quartet of characters. Setting out on a helicopter tour of Antarctica (after the obligatory stock footage to establish verisimilitude) are the Stalwart Commander, the Spunky Female Correspondent, the Regular Guy, and the Panicky Guy.  They crash land in the inevitable warm zone where the constant temps have forestalled evolution through the eons. In other words…dinosaurs.

As you’d expect from the lean running time, events continue apace. Within 15 minutes they have crashed, there’s a malfunction that they can’t fix and the radio can’t cut through the thick atmosphere. There’s a villain—basically Wolf Larsen combined with the stranded guy from Treasure Island—who conveniently has a spare part they need. He’s willing to trade it for the lady, which of course is no go. I usually disdain having a human villain to pull attention away from the fantastic elements, but this guy is a great character and integrated very well with the monster action.


The real stars are the monsters. And man, they are glorious. There’s a sequence or two of your typically real lizards dressed up like dinosaurs. Modern viewers will surely wince at the way the two monitor lizards in question are set to fiercely fight and maim each other for our supposed amusement. More to the point, the use of real lizards clashes with the mindboggingly incredible dinosaur suits and puppets, which are what truly elevate the film to classic status for me.

It’s the typical roster: giant man-eating plant, pterodactyls, a truly nifty plesiosaur that lurks in a lagoon and attacks the unwary. Then there’s the capper, what remains my absolute favorite movie T-Rex of all time. I get why most people vastly prefer the realistic CGI Rexes of your Jurassic Parks and whatnot. However, seeing this fabulous guy-in-suit dino simply balms my soul. You can talk about how it looks goofy, or snicker about patent origins as a man in a suit. I don’t care, it is exactly what I want from a film like this. I don’t want my dinosaurs to be animals, I want them to be monsters, and these really fill that bill.

Anyway, enough blathering from me. I know everyone here—all like ten of you—must have a ‘50s sci-fi film that you hold close to your heart, even if it’s not one of the acknowledged classics. What are they, and why?

  • Beckoning Chasm

    I don’t know if it’s considered a classic or not, but I like “Earth vs the Flying Saucers.” The saucers are one of the best sci-fi spaceships ever. Also “The Mysterians” though the movie is kind of a mess.

  • I think my favorite non-classic sci-fi film (and the one that scared me the most) is THE GIANT BEHEMOTH.

    I do have soft spots for “The Monster that Challenged the World” and “The Black Scorpion,” too.

  • Gamera977

    It’s too early on a Monday to think. I’ll get back with you later…

  • thunderclancat

    Night of the Blood Beast- Not a classic, perhaps but I was always intrigued by the plot of the monster that wants to supposedly save save “humanity from itself” but does so by attacking and killing.

    I also liked The Blob.

  • bgbear_rnh

    “Teenagers from Outer Space” is much better than expected

  • X the Unknown is one of the best Blob movies out there without the Blob in the title. I also have a soft spot for Caltiki the Immortal Monster.

    I also want to second everything else mentioned so far. Fifties was a blast, Sci Fi wise.

  • Eric Hinkle

    I’ve pretty much got to give a ‘me too’ on all the films already mentioned. Invisible Invaders is another weirdly endearing film, as is Fiend Without A Face.

    If I may go off on a tangent, though it’s not remotely a SF film — it feels more like a classic 40’s horror piece — I do love 1957’s Night of the Demon as one of the best horror movies of all time.

  • Gamera977

    I’m very much partial to ‘X The Unknown’ and ‘Night of the Demon’ as well.

    I’d go with ‘Forbidden Planet’ and ‘Gojira’ too.

    Plus I don’t think anyone listed the Disney version of ‘20,000 Leagues Under The Sea’ though I guess it would be a ‘classic’ SF film.

  • Gamera977

    Just got back from ‘Ghostbusters: Afterlife’ and it was fun! It did have some pacing issues and leaned a little hard on nostalgia but I liked it. A fine tribute to the original cast near the end and a big sweet tribute to the late Harold Ramis!

  • Ken_Begg

    I was thinking X the Unknown would get a shout out. It’s a great little movie. And yes, man, the ’50s was so good. More great sci-fi films, arguably (for a certain viewer demographic anyway) than all the other decades put together.

  • Eric Hinkle

    I thought we were supposed to be going for the ‘non-classic’ 50’s SF. Aren’t Forbidden Planet and Gojira normally grouped in with “real” and “meaningful” movies by critics?

    Personally I like them both.

  • Ken_Begg

    Yeah, I’d have to say certainly Forbidden Planet is one of the decade’s very best, and Gojira’s stock has really risen over the past few decades.

  • Gamera977

    Sorry guess I wasn’t clear. I listed them separately because they are classics. My apologies.

  • I’m gonna go with “A Bucket of Blood”. Dick Miller at his best. And the idea that anyone could look at those gloppy blobs and consider them fabulously valuable art is just so ridonkulously risible, yet also entirely believable, given some of the Modern “Art” I’ve seen. It just makes me happy, is what I’m saying.

  • Eric Hinkle

    I remember loving a scene in that movie where one of the ‘Oh, how I loathe filthy capitalism’ beatnik types is openly gloating over how much cash the art show will be raking in. Dick Miller’s character confusedly asks how he can be saying that given his contempt for cash. The beatnik responds, “I said I despise money — but not THIS much money!” Felt like Corman was making a comment about the arthouse crowd there.

  • Yep, wonder how that would go over with the current crowd of baby Marxists? Because it seems just as up to date these days.

  • Ken_Begg

    Corman proved you could be both a beatnik–or sympathetic to them–and a stone cold capitalist. His films are nearly uniformly good exactly because he always prioritized the latter trait.

  • Rodford Smith

    _The Monolith Monsters_.

  • Eric Hinkle

    Ooh, that’s a good one. I loved ti ever since I first saw it as a boy. It helped to be seeing it with parents who grew up when polio epidemics were still a thing and who could explain just how terrifying the sight of those iron lungs would have been when it first came out.

  • Ken_Begg

    I’ve written before about how I like the non-sentient movies of the ’50s; MM, the Blob, Kronos, Magnetic Monster, etc. As a Universal film, this one obviously had very good production values to boot.

  • The Rev.

    This was one of the first horror movies I remember seeing. I was young enough to not know who Medusa was, so this was my first experience with people being petrified, and the idea frankly terrified me, especially since it wasn’t instantaneous.